AUDI S3 VS VOLKSWAGEN GOLF 8R: SAME, SAME, BUT DIFFERENT.
When it comes to hot hatches, few rivalries carry as much weight as Audi’s S3 and Volkswagen’s Golf R. They share DNA - both born of the VW Group MQB platform, both powered by variations of the same 2.0-litre turbocharged four-cylinder - but they wear very different badges and play to slightly different crowds. The question is, which one gives you more for your money in 2025? On paper, the Audi S3 edges ahead. Its updated 2.0-litre turbo pushes out 245 kW and 420 Nm, launching the hatchback from 0-100 km/h in a brisk 4.7 seconds. That’s a tenth quicker than the Golf R, which comes in at 235 kW and 400 Nm, good for a 4.8-second sprint. Both are capped at the usual 250 km/h, but it’s the way they deliver the performance that separates them.
The S3 borrows serious kit from its big brother, the RS 3 - most notably the torque splitter. This clever system actively distributes torque to each rear wheel, sharpening agility and even unlocking a drift mode when Dynamic Plus is engaged. Throw in stiffer suspension components, progressive steering, and beefier brakes, and the S3 is sharper, more focused, and just that little bit closer to RS territory. The Golf R fights back with pedigree and polish. It may lack the torque splitter trickery, but its 4Motion all-wheel-drive system has been fine-tuned over decades of development. It, too, now comes with a drift mode, and with optional Adaptive Chassis Control, it offers an impressively broad spread of abilities - from comfortable cruiser to track-day toy.
Audi plays the premium card, and it plays it well. The latest S3 features subtle yet aggressive styling updates, a new gear selector, ambient lighting, and a slick infotainment interface that even allows custom light designs to be uploaded. Inside, the vibe is more restrained but undeniably upmarket, with a choice between hatchback practicality in the Sportback or the sleek appeal of the Sedan. The Golf R, meanwhile, leans into its cult status with a spec sheet that reads like a gadget lover’s dream. Think panoramic sunroof, wireless charging, matrix LED headlights, Nappa leather R sport seats, and an optional Akrapovič titanium exhaust that turns the already punchy four-pot into a soundtrack worth chasing tunnels for. Throw in the Harman Kardon sound system and a head-up display, and the Golf R blends everyday usability with flashes of luxury you wouldn’t expect in a humble Golf.
Driving Experience - This is where the line is drawn. The S3 is for those who want a sharper, more driver-focused experience in their daily performance car. With its RS-inspired hardware, it encourages you to push harder and rewards you with precision and poise. It’s a true junior RS. The Golf R, however, is arguably the more rounded package. It’s marginally softer in character, but that translates to more comfort on long journeys and a greater ability to multitask. It can do the school run, the daily commute, and then attack a mountain pass without breaking stride. And thanks to its broad list of driver aids - from Travel Assist to Lane Keep and Autonomous Emergency Braking - it’s arguably the more practical pick.
This is also a battle of legacies. The Golf R traces its roots back to the legendary Mk4 R32 of the early 2000s - the car that really kicked off the modern AWD hot hatch craze. Since then, every generation of Golf R has refined the recipe, and the Mk8 is the most powerful, most advanced iteration yet. The Audi S3, meanwhile, has long been the more upmarket sibling, dating back to 1999 when it introduced the concept of a premium, compact AWD performance car. Over the years, it’s built a reputation for subtlety and sophistication - a car for those who want pace without shouting about it.
So, Audi S3 or Golf R? If you want sharp handling, RS-inspired performance, and that premium badge appeal, the new Audi S3 is the one to go for. It’s the more exciting car from behind the wheel and a genuine step up in driver involvement. But if you want the ultimate all-rounder - the hot hatch that can do everything, everywhere, with a tech-packed interior and cult status baked into its DNA - the Golf R remains the king of usability. Whichever way you lean, you’re getting one of the best all-wheel-drive hot hatches ever built. And really, that’s the beauty of this rivalry: two cars, same roots, totally different personalities.
Take a look at the YouTube video from the chaps at Car Throttle as they delve in to the differences - and similarities - between the Golf R and it's close cousin, the Audi S3 - They're close on paper, but if we were to spend a million bucks, we'd have the Golf - because R: We Drove the Audi S3 and VW Golf R - Which Is Best? | Car Throttle
Be sure to check out our YouTube channel here for more exciting and exclusive SXdrv content! And don't forget to smash that subscribe button!